Markan Priority and the Synoptic Problem

Matthew, Mark, and Luke often tell the same stories in the same order and even in closely similar wording. The Synoptic Problem is the question of how that overlap should be explained. Most specialists today hold Markan priority: Mark was written first, and Matthew and Luke used Mark. That is the majority position, not a unanimous one.

How Matthew and Luke relate to each other is more contested. The two-source hypothesis adds a lost sayings source, often called Q, to explain material that Matthew and Luke share but Mark lacks. The Farrer approach instead argues that Luke used Matthew as well as Mark, which would make Q unnecessary. Other models exist. The point for readers is that later Gospels can be watched revising a shared narrative, which is a form of redaction criticism with the evidence still on the page.

A comparison in outline: Markan priority is widely held. The existence of Q is debated. Independence of all three Gospels is a minority view in current critical scholarship. Articles on this site use those tools on passages such as the desolating sacrilege, the birth narratives, and the composition of Mark.

Articles on this site

Related guides

Scroll to Top